The Financial Markets Authority (FMA) reviewed the licence conditions for derivatives issuers. The changes are aimed at protecting retail investors trading complex and higher-risk financial products. Further information on the FMA’s review is available here.
The adjustment follows a lengthy review and consultation process over the last two years. The FMA’s submissions report on the 2024 consultation is available here. Its Regulatory Impact Statement is available here.
The updated Standard Conditions for Derivatives Issuer licences are available here.
The changes come into effect on 18 November 2027. The new leverage condition is available here and the varied suitability condition is available here.
Who needs to read it? Why?
All derivatives issuers need to read the Regulatory Impact Statement and the updated licence conditions.
The new conditions directly impact derivatives issuers’ compliance obligations.
What does it cover?
Variation to suitability condition
Licensed derivatives issuers are subject to conditions imposed under the Financial Markets Conduct Act 2013 (FMCA), the Financial Markets Conduct Regulations 2014 (FMCR), and the standard conditions for market services licensees.
In December 2020, the FMA conducted a sector risk assessment which found that a quarter of derivatives issuers licensed at the time were not taking reasonable steps to make suitability assessments.
The revised condition is designed to strengthen suitability assessments before onboarding retail investors, and promote the purposes of the FMCA. The FMA considers that failing to properly assess suitability means investors do not understand the risks associated with a product’s complexity, counterparty risk, liquidity, or leverage.
Variations to the suitability condition will come into effect on 18 November 2027. The varied suitability condition contains the following key differences:
- Suitability assessments will move from whether a retail investor “has the ability to understand” the particular derivative and its risks to taking all reasonable steps to “determine whether the retail investor understands” the risks involved.
- If a retail investor provides insufficient information to assess suitability, elects not to provide it, or is assessed as not understanding the particular type of derivative and its risks, the issuer is barred from entering the transaction. The varied condition removes the existing discretion to proceed with the transaction having requested further information from the investor through a written warning.
- The varied condition removes the express exception for issuers who already have information to make a suitability assessment. If issuers have insufficient information, they must request information on the individual’s “knowledge, experience and level of understanding" of the particular type of derivative and the risks involved.
- Requirements for retail investors who are not individuals, previously set out in the explanatory note, have been incorporated into the operative condition. From 18 November 2027, issuers must take all reasonable steps to determine whether the relevant directors, employees or agents acting on behalf of the retail investor, individually or collectively as appropriate, understand the particular type of derivative and the risks involved, rather than merely have the ability to understand them.
- All derivatives issuers must now retain records of suitability assessments to comply with the varied condition.
New leverage condition
Currently, derivatives issuers are not required to comply with any leverage limits. The FMA considers that offering highly leveraged derivatives to retail investors without adequate investor protections to mitigate the risks increases the likelihood that investors will lose their margin, owing additional money to the issuer. The FMA considers that a leverage condition will better promote the purposes of the FMCA.
The leverage condition will:
- apply only to derivatives issuers offering leverage above the limits set out in the leverage condition;
- require an over the counter (OTC) derivative offered by the issuer to a retail investor to include prescribed minimum initial margin requirements based on the nature of the underlying derivative, limiting the extent to which the investor is permitted to be leveraged; and
- derivatives issuers will now be required to close out an investor’s open positions if the net equity in the investor’s account falls below the aggregate margin required to maintain those permissions.
Licensed derivatives issuers will still be able to continue offering highly leveraged products to retail investors if they have three specified investor protections (negative balance protection, 50% minimum margin requirement, and vulnerable investor framework) in place.
Our view
The FMA’s media release comes shortly after its review of fees disclosures. That review included PDS requirements aimed at providing retail investors with clear and consistent fee disclosures. You can find out more about the FMA’s review of fee disclosures here. The subsequent review of requirements for derivatives issuers suggests that retail investor protection is a high priority at the FMA.
FMA General Counsel Liam Mason stated that the motivation behind the licence conditions for derivatives issuers was to “help ensure people better understand the products they are trading and support informed investment decisions. They will also require firms to take greater responsibility for determining whether a product is suitable before a retail investor is allowed to trade it.”
The FMA has signalled that it will continue to monitor outcomes for derivatives issuers and investors.
What next:
If you have any questions about the new licence conditions for derivatives issuers, contact one of our experts.
This article was co-authored by Sarah Waller, a Solicitor in our Financial Services team.